Attack on the independent publication Gândul, the strongest opposition newspaper in Romania. For more than two months, Facebook has shut down the newspaper’s page with 1 million followers and refuses to restore it

The newspaper’s social media extension-certified by Facebook with a “blue checkmark”-had over 1 million followers and generated hundreds of millions of views each month. Facebook is drastically limiting the public’s right to access information from the Gândul platform.

In the absence of explanations regarding the restriction, and considering that the newspaper has acted in good faith and followed journalistic ethics in informing the public, we consider this action by Facebook to be an attack on press freedom in general and on an independent publication in particular, as well as a violation of rights guaranteed by the Romanian Constitution and the law, as we will demonstrate below.

It is astonishing how an entity like Facebook can wipe out, with a single click, years of work by journalists. We are witnessing an abuse by an entity among a group of giants that, although they operate and collect hundreds of millions of euros from Romanian citizens, practically do not exist in Romania, do not pay taxes to the Romanian state, and are not accountable to authorities. There are several examples, including companies such as Uber, which are protected and engage in unfair competition with Romanian entrepreneurs.

Șase activiști antirăzboi condamnați la pedepse grele cu închisoare în Rusia

Veolia România continuă Olimpiada de Biodiversitate „Natura dintre Ape”, la nivel național

We will discuss all of this in detail in the next article, as is customary at Gândul, with documents and figures.

We hereby call on all authorities that protect citizens, the Constitution, rights and freedoms, as well as those responsible for regulating free competition, to take action regarding this measure, which we consider an abuse of power: the Romanian Parliament, the Romanian Government, the National Authority for Administration and Regulation in Communications (ANCOM), the Competition Council, the European Commission through the Directorate-General for Competition, etc.

Facebook’s action, its dominant market position, and its ability to abuse this status represent a serious attack on freedom of expression and free-market competition.

Freedom of expression at the mercy of algorithms and opaque decisions by online platforms

Restricting an extension of the online newspaper through which Gândul articles reached over 1 million users implicitly means restricting press freedom and freedom of expression.

At Gândul, we sincerely believe in the role of the press to criticize those in power, regardless of political color—but with arguments, evidence, and solid documentation. We do not consider it a mere coincidence that the Facebook page was shut down, given that the newspaper is the strongest opposition publication in Romania, especially since, as we will show below, Gândul resolved amicably all the “issues” indicated by Facebook that led to the shutdown, and there is no real reason for the page to remain closed.

Facebook’s action, its dominant market position, and its ability to abuse this status represent a serious attack on freedom of expression and free-market competition.

Freedom of expression at the mercy of algorithms and opaque decisions by online platforms

Restricting an extension of the online newspaper through which Gândul articles reached over 1 million users implicitly means restricting press freedom and freedom of expression.

At Gândul, we sincerely believe in the role of the press to criticize those in power, regardless of political color—but with arguments, evidence, and solid documentation. We do not consider it a mere coincidence that the Facebook page was shut down, given that the newspaper is the strongest opposition publication in Romania, especially since, as we will show below, Gândul resolved amicably all the “issues” indicated by Facebook that led to the shutdown, and there is no real reason for the page to remain closed.

Facebook causes major damage to the newspaper in relation to competition

Facebook is seriously disrupting free competition in Romania’s media market. By preventing Gândul from distributing its articles on Facebook through its own page, the newspaper suffers major competitive harm.

We are unable to reach Gândul readers and followers on Facebook, while other competing newspapers have unrestricted access. This results in financial losses that our competitors do not bear. Consequently, the company’s operational capacity declines, along with its ability to invest, while other companies’ revenues are unaffected by Facebook.

Thus, by restricting access to the page, Facebook directly intervenes and violates the principle of free competition between companies—an essential pillar of democracy and capitalism.

Beyond principles, Facebook is also violating Competition Law no. 21/1996, Article 6:
“The abusive use of a dominant position […] through anti-competitive practices that have as their object or effect the restriction, prevention, or distortion of competition is prohibited.”

In one day, a page with 1 million followers was wiped out

Facebook continues to refuse to provide a clear explanation for its action and has cited copyright infringement. Such copyright disputes, inherent in publishing activity, were resolved directly within the platform with the companies that filed the complaints. Nevertheless, despite all claims being resolved, Facebook continues to penalize Gândul.

Thus, by restricting access to the page, Facebook directly intervenes and violates the principle of free competition between companies—an essential pillar of democracy and capitalism.

Beyond principles, Facebook is also violating Competition Law no. 21/1996, Article 6:
“The abusive use of a dominant position […] through anti-competitive practices that have as their object or effect the restriction, prevention, or distortion of competition is prohibited.”

Below is the timeline of events, along with correspondence with Facebook:

The restriction was applied to the Gândul Facebook account on February 22, between approximately 10:00–12:00.

At the same time, we received a notification stating that one of our videos allegedly violated intellectual property rules. However, when attempting to access the page, no reason for the suspension was provided.

We immediately opened a ticket with Meta, which responded requesting additional information, which we provided.

We also contacted the company that filed the intellectual property complaint.

Subsequently, all complaints were resolved amicably, as shown in the screenshot below.

As can be seen, they are marked “Closed.”

Furthermore, Facebook itself states that we did not violate any “community standards.”

Despite this, we have received no further response, and for five weeks the Gândul page has been unable to publish.

As can be seen, they are marked “Closed.”

Furthermore, Facebook itself states that we did not violate any “community standards.”

Despite this, we have received no further response, and for five weeks the Gândul page has been unable to publish.